Homemade In-N-Out Spread - The Recipe Critic (2024)

FAQs

What is spread made out of from In-N-Out? ›

Spread 'em: Mastering the Special Sauce

I never understood why In-N-Out refers to their sauce as "Spread." Maybe they're just a little too cool for school. In any case, all it is is a basic Thousand Island-style dressing: a mixture of ketchup, mayonnaise, and sweet pickle relish.

What is In-N-Out Burger Spread? In-N-Out Burger Spread is a creamy and tangy sauce that brings a signature flavor to In-N-Out's burgers. It's a blend of mayonnaise, ketchup, and sweet pickle relish, with a hint of sugar to balance the flavors.

This chain has plenty of well-known items on its menu, and the special In-N-Out sauce makes their signature burgers just that much better. It's often mistaken (by the naked eye) for Thousand Island dressing, but this spread has its own distinct flavor.

The website of In-N-Out publicizes "some of the most popular items" on what it calls the not-so-secret menu. Animal Style is one of the most popular secret styles. In addition to the standard toppings burgers in that range include mustard fried on each meat patty, pickles, grilled onions, and extra spread.

A sandwich spread is a spreadable condiment used in a sandwich, in addition to more solid ingredients. Butter, mayonnaise, prepared mustard, and ketchup are typical sandwich spreads, along with their variants such as Thousand Island dressing, tartar sauce, and Russian dressing.

Our team of Associates removes the bones, grinds the meat and then makes each patty. We have always made our hamburger patties ourselves using only fresh, 100% USDA ground chuck — free of additives, fillers and preservatives.

The original recipe for Thousand Island was also blended with a hard-boiled egg to help thicken it, and it was seasoned with a splash of Worcestershire sauce (via NPR). In-N-Out's burger spread, on the other hand, simply contains mayo, ketchup, sweet pickle relish, and a splash of vinegar.

Thousand Island dressing is an American salad dressing and condiment based on mayonnaise and usually ketchup or tomato purée and chopped pickles; it can also include lemon juice, orange juice, paprika, black pepper, Worcestershire sauce, mustard, vinegar, cream, chili sauce, olive oil, and hot sauce.

Green relish, onion, French dressing, Mayo. If anyone here thinks that thousand island dressing and big Mac sauce are the same thing then you're wrong.  two completely different sauces.

What cheese does In-N-Out use? ›

In-N-Out At Home. Known for its juicy burgers, melty American Cheese, and grilled onions and fresh onions, lettuce, tomatoes and the most delicious burger sauce.

While fry sauce is not the same as Thousand Island or Burger Sauce, it is still similar with the use of mayo as the base. In our fry sauce recipe, we use: Mayonnaise. Ketchup.

Monkey/Gorilla Style: any burger with animal fries in the middle – most stores will not make this combination.

Other not-so-secret orders include “Roadkill Fries” with hamburger meat crumbled on top, “Grilled Cheese, “Animal Fries” and a “Scooby Snack,” which is just a patty in a wrapper.

For those unfamiliar, a Flying Dutchman consists of a hamburger with grilled onions in place of the bun. The burger is also topped with American cheese and a sauce made from mayo, ketchup and relish (similar to the one on this burger).

Heinz Sandwich Spread is a blend of salad cream and relish manufactured by Heinz and popular in the Netherlands and Britain. It is classified by the manufacturer as a sauce or relish.

Ketchup & Mustard Swap: If you aren't a fan of their spread (it's basically Thousand Island and is dairy-free), you can order ketchup and mustard instead.

Treehugger Tip. Beware anything animal-style at In-n-Out. For burgers, this means you get lettuce, tomato, pickles, cheese, grilled onions, and a "secret" spread that many liken to Thousand Island dressing. The dressing and cheese (and, of course, the meat) are not vegan.